QAG Grading Scale

A 1–10 scale that explains both the card’s condition and the evidence behind it. The overall grade is not an automatic copy of the lowest subgrade.

  • Two 10 tiers
  • 0.5 steps
  • Evidence first
Sumi-e inspection study showing a card measured through multiple evidence fields
A grade is a reading of evidence

Read the number correctly

Subgrades show where a card is strong and where defects appear. The overall grade is calculated from the finalized subgrades, with the weakest area carrying the most weight.

01

Four pillars

Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface are the four core inspection fields.

02

Front + back

Front and back values stay visible; each pillar uses (front + back) ÷ 2, floored to QAG’s 0.5 ladder.

03

Final grade

The overall grade is not a raw sum or a single minimum; it is published after review.

A subgrade is evidence—not the final verdict

One subgrade of 9 does not mechanically force an overall 9. Conversely, a severe defect can limit the grade ceiling even when the other pillars are strong.

  1. 01

    Measure the evidence

    Review the relevant images and measurements for both sides.

  2. 02

    Score each pillar

    Summarize Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface independently.

  3. 03

    Set the overall grade

    Consider balance, defect weight, and the limiting factor before publication.

Card condition levels

Every level, from 1 to 10 in half-point steps. A grade of 10 has two distinct tiers.

The highest QAG distinction

10

KAMI

QAG’s highest tier. Every condition below must be met.

  • Overall 10, with all four subgrades at 10 on both front and back.
  • Measured 50/50 centering horizontally and vertically on both sides.
  • No confirmed defects, with finalized evidence reviewed before publication.
10

Pristine

An overall grade of 10 that does not meet every KAMI condition.

The number 10 alone does not mean KAMI. Read the tier printed on the label and certificate.

  1. 10

    KAMI

    QAG’s highest tier: virtually flawless under detailed review and clear of all KAMI gates.

  2. 10

    Pristine

    A 10 with premium condition that does not meet one or more KAMI conditions.

  3. 9.5

    Gem Mint

    Premium condition with only extremely minor issues found under close inspection.

  4. 9

    Mint

    Sharp and clean, with minor issues that do not undermine the overall presentation.

  5. 8.5

    Near Mint–Mint+

    Very strong condition with minor manufacturing or handling issues.

  6. 8

    Near Mint–Mint

    Very good condition with light evidence of handling visible on close review.

  7. 7.5

    Near Mint+

    Several light signs of wear, while the overall presentation remains strong.

  8. 7

    Near Mint

    More visible wear, but the card still presents well.

  9. 6.5

    Excellent–Mint+

    A moderate small flaw or several minor flaws are visible.

  10. 6

    Excellent–Mint

    Manufacturing or handling wear is clearly more apparent.

  11. 5.5

    Excellent+

    Multiple issues are present, while the card remains presentable.

  12. 5

    Excellent

    Visible wear and surface or edge issues affect the presentation.

  13. 4.5

    Very Good–Excellent+

    Several issues combine and begin to affect eye appeal.

  14. 4

    Very Good–Excellent

    More advanced wear is present, including possible light pressure marks or creases.

  15. 3.5

    Very Good+

    A significant flaw is present, but the card remains clearly legible and viewable.

  16. 3

    Very Good

    Multiple visible flaws materially affect the overall presentation.

  17. 2.5

    Good+

    Some heavy damage is present, such as a clear crease or advanced wear.

  18. 2

    Good

    Multiple heavy creases or substantial wear are present.

  19. 1.5

    Fair

    One or more severe defects are present.

  20. 1

    Poor

    Heavy damage substantially affects the card’s structure or presentation.

These condition names describe QAG’s scale and do not promise an equivalent grade from another company.

A report should be traceable

Every published score should lead back to approved evidence. QAG shows subgrades, front and back values, the limiting factor, and the appropriate review images without exposing private scanner data.

QAG is independent and is not affiliated with PSA, BGS, CGC, TAG, or any card publisher.